Gerad on Sid Meir’s Civilization

In 1996, many Friday nights looked something like this: cassette tapes of my favorite songs (taped off the radio of course), a couple cans of iced tea, some pizza, and Civilization 2. I generally played as the Celts, a vague sort of hat-tip to my emerging cultural pride (I’m Gerad Francis O’Shea after all). My strategy was simple: accept peace accords from any friendly societies, focus on developing new technologies but never trade them, move quickly towards developing The Great Library, never pay tribute (especially not to Napoleon), never engage in alliances against anybody unless the request came from Native-American societies, only fight wars if completely necessary; and if they were, crush the opponent[1].

The Sid Meir’s Civilization franchise has sold over 8 million units over the last 25 years and is widely considered one of the best “strategy” franchises of all-time. Civilization IV was listed as #2 on IGN’s 2007 Top 25 PC Games of All Time. Most everybody agrees that these games are great but they are rarely, if ever, considered an educational game.

Is world domination the purpose of the game? Yes.

Can you acquire nuclear weapons and vaporize entire societies? Yes.

Is it really fun and really addicting to play? Yes and yes.

Okay, there is suggested violence in this game (no blood, no personal combat). But there is also real and integrated educational content. As part of one’s pursuit of world domination, one must create settlements, irrigate the land, build roads, create a sustainable agricultural economy, chose from new and developing forms of government to influence civic output and civil unrest, manage alliances with actual ancient societies and decide which technologies to pursue to shape your available units and civil structures (e.g. “should I discover the wheel so I can recruit chariots, or develop literacy and build a library?”). I can still name the Seven Wonders of the World through my Civ II gaming, though they have probably changed since I was in 8th grade.

Gaming is supposed to be fun! It’s not fun to solve math equations on a touch screen so you can earn a chance to throw ninja stars at a giant cat (that’s a real app). Great educators will tell you that comprehension is often best achieved by using skills in an applied setting. If a game is primarily applied math (economics) and problem solving directly related to real historical events, how is it not an educational game!? It should be considered a model for integrated curriculum.

It is important to consider Civ II, and the entire Civilization franchise, as the app store becomes increasingly cluttered with shallow flashcard apps. Not all games need to be educational, but all games have to be fun! That’s the point. It would be great if more educational games resembled the successful and engaging “non-education” games.


[1] I would later read The Prince by Machiavlli and learn that he had nothing on my middle school gamer-self.
Email
  • Traditional and Novel Modes of Activity in Touch Screen Math Apps

    We describe conclusions from an analysis of touch screen math apps for 3-7-year old children. The analysis revealed that apps are heavily shaped by existing cultural practices associated with both math (a question & answer or quiz format) and digital devices (video/computer/handheld games). These formats obscure the potential for touch screen apps that afford novel ways for interacting with math concepts. Yet they persist because they embody widely accepted ways of doing things with clearly defined social purposes. A few apps exemplify the potential for novel forms of touch screen interaction. Integrating these apps into mainstream math education requires a reconceptualization of how math learning and assessment can occur. Click this link to access the full report.  

  • MCG Visits MoMA’s Century of the Child Exhibit

    This exhibit has a wonderful website: http://www.moma.org/interactives/exhibitions/2012/centuryofthechild The Museum of Modern Art here in New York is currently presenting an exhibition of The Century of the Child: Growing by Design, 1900-2000.  The exhibition runs through November 5, 2012.  The entire MCG Team recently went for a visit and here is an overview of what we experienced. One of the characteristics of Western industrialized societies is their interest in the child as a separate entity from the adult. Since the Victorian period (1890s), children have often been the focus of social criticism and innovation. While this exhibit focuses on “the material world of the modern child” in Europe and the U.S., it doesn’t neglect the social and intellectual aspects of this new concept of childhood. At the beginning of the 20thcentury, both the Arts & Crafts and Art Nouveau movements focused on the unity of all the arts, attempting to reunite the fine arts with the craft occupations and techniques. Both movements also used organic forms and colors to shape their art. The “New Art” movement incorporated both Arts & Crafts and Art Nouveau, and this approach was used to “shape the material world of the modern child”(Retrieved from http://www.moma.org/interactives/exhibitions/2012/centuryofthechild/#/timeline/new-century on 8/17/12). The new focus on children as individuals who are different from adults, and who have different needs, coincided with an explosion of innovation and an artistic focus on children. Avant-Garde artists looked for ways to release the childlike creativity within them. They also created new forms of furniture, toys, books, and interiors that would allow children to “release their youthful energy and imagination” (retrieved from http://www.moma.org/interactives/exhibitions/2012/centuryofthechild/#/timeline/avant-garde-playtime on 8/17/12). The interwar period (1920-30) was a time of idealism and concern with nurturing children and providing healthy and uplifting environments for them. The design of school buildings with access to light and air, toys like the Skippy Racer (an early scooter), and comfortable, durable clothing, embodied these goals. Many aspects of these designs are still with us today. During World War II, another side of this intense focus on children surfaced. Art and design were used in posters, children’s games, children’s clothing and books, to teach children their place in society and to encourage hatred of the enemies of their societies. During World War II, toy companies on both sides produced games that depicted the enemies of the Axis and the Allies as silly, stupid, and evil. Organizations like the Girl and Boy Scouts in the U.S., the Hitler Youth in Germany, and the Pioneers in the Soviet Union, involved their young members in wartime activities. In the postwar period, the children of many of the industrialized countries became the harbingers of a new, expansive, and utopian society. They also became consumers, as billion-dollar industries arose to meet the new demand for children’s books, toys, clothing, media, foods and a host of other products. This trend has continued, in spite of considerate opposition to the targeting of children by advertisers. The brave, new digital world that children are growing up into now offers both the promise of more freedom for children, in the ways that they play, learn, and communicate, and the dangers of more freedom in that they can be exposed to information and people that can be dangerous to them. Children can also harm others in a virtual world where their behavior may not be monitored in the same ways it is in the physical world. The digitalization of both children’s games and educational materials is leading to the development of new skills and new ways of learning older skills. Our job as educational researchers is to support the development of new products by discovering what characteristics of these products are effective in conveying new ideas and teaching new skills. For us, looking backward at the inspiring designs and concepts of the last century, was fascinating, as was looking forward to the educational and recreational environments that allow children the freedom they need to become the inventors of the 21st century.

  • Sony Wonderbook Review

    When Sony announced the Wonderbook, many people in the gaming media industry were wondering what to expect. The device straddles the line between game and storybook, and at times it is hard to say for sure whether you are playing it or reading it.  Wonderbook promises,” One Book: a Thousand Stories,” in a device that is aimed at captivating a new generation of children. The Wonderbook is an Augmented Reality (AR) reading device, which makes use of the Playstation 3, Playstation Eye, and Playstation Move peripherals to project images and animations onto its pages. The result is an interactive storybook that a child can play with in ways that a traditional pop-up book or iPad app cannot be used. Below is SONY's promotional trailer for the device, as well as a gameplay demo of one of the Wonderbook's first stories, Harry Potter's Book of Spells. The latter provides an excellent example of how gameplay/reading works on the device. Thus far, Sony has announced three titles for Wonderbook, the previously mentioned Harry Potter Book of Spells, BBC’s Walking With Dinosaurs, and Diggs Nightcrawler. The first book allows players to take the role of a student at Hogwarts School (the magic academy at the center of the Harry Potter series), learning and practicing spells from the series. Walking with Dinosaurs mixes archeology with 3D recreations to bring players back to a time where dinosaurs ruled the earth. Digg’s Nightcrawler is a humorous detective-noir story that gives children the opportunity to solve a mystery, involving children’s fairytale characters like Humpty-Dumpty. Much of the dialogue from the story is based on hardboiled detective dramas like the Maltese Falcon. Beyond the device’s technology, what really interests me about Wonderbook is that each of these game’s creators have taken their concept in a unique direction. Book of Spells allows players to become immersed in the World of Harry Potter. Playing/reading the title is highly activity based, which contrasts with Digg’s Nightcrawler’s theme of telling an interactive story. Walking with Dinosaurs appears to be a middle ground, using small activities to bridge the gap between present and prehistoric times. Promotional Trailer: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AHgev9b5E0A Harry Potter's Book of Spells: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MPYUkbP5Kh4 Walking with Dinosaurs: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kRQ5GBzjt0 Nightcrawler: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xotqMmZfa0I